Skip to content
Zoe Reilly

What sterility test failures are really telling us

Every sterility test failure starts with a question. And the wrong one can cost months, morale, and trust. Zoë Reilly shares what actually separates a productive investigation from a defensive one.

Learn more

How a failure investigation begins

When you’ve lived through enough sterility test failures, you develop a certain fluency with them. You learn how investigations unfold, where pressure builds, and how quickly the stakes escalate. But for the teams inside a failure—with millions of dollars, patient safety, and sometimes careers on the line—that perspective is hard to maintain.

I supported more sterility testing failure investigations early in my career than most experience in a lifetime, across various large pharmaceutical manufacturing organizations. I’ve seen the full range of reactions: defensiveness, fear, and exhaustion.

What I’ve learned is that the most dangerous moment in a sterility test failure is not the failure itself, but rather the first question asked. Too often, that question is some version of “What did QC do wrong?” or “How did the lab mess this up?” Those are the wrong questions.

Being the investigational testing “rockstar” called in to investigate every failure was, in many ways, the opportunity of a lifetime: highly visible, intellectually challenging, even creative. But it was also difficult and abrasive. When the FDA or EMA enters the picture, the pressure escalates instantly. You’re no longer just speaking for your lab; you’re representing an entire company and its reputation.

Ultimately, it was burnout from supporting repeated sterility test failures that led me to leave the pharma QC laboratory to move into sterility assurance technology.

“Staying open is insanely important. You don’t go into a crime scene assuming you already know who the culprit is”.

Zoë Reilly, SKAN US Sterility Assurance Sr. Technical Expert

What’s at stake: The cost of getting it wrong

Investigations are exhausting because the stakes are so high and the timelines so long. A single sterility test failure can put millions of dollars at risk through delayed release or lost batches. Mid-range and senior experts are pulled into investigations for months, often while still carrying their day jobs. Entire teams operate under sustained pressure, and exhaustion becomes a constant undercurrent.

That’s because sterility tests are apart of the final check before drugs are released to patients. These are products that go straight into the bloodstream. They must be absolutely sterile. The risk of infection from even a single microorganism that shouldn’t be there is real.

What makes sterility test investigations even harder is that in many cases, the true cause is never found; yet teams are still required to demonstrate rigorous diligence, exploring every plausible scenario and presenting a defensible case to regulators. This is because microorganisms are microscopic, and therefore impossible to see with the naked eye. Depending on the organism, growth in sterility test media may be rapid or very slow, with failures detected anywhere from early in the test window to much later.

And sterility tests capture only a single moment in time. Since both laboratory and manufacturing protocols require constant cleaning, potential evidence is routinely removed. It’s like cleaning up the scene of the crime every single day.

Culture, not the test, is what fails

Despite everything that makes sterility test failures so painful—the stress, the fear, the burnout—they are also extraordinarily revealing. An investigation of this magnitude is the perfect snapshot of how a company’s quality system actually works: which protocols are in place, how teams collaborate under pressure, and where assumptions replace evidence.

The best investigations happen when teams stay curious instead of defensive. I recall one where a tiny piece of rubber was found along the manufacturing product path. Rather than dismissing it, we aseptically tested it and recovered a single organism—Ralstonia pickettii, a microorganism commonly associated with water systems—which traced the failure back to a breakdown in rubber tubing within the filling equipment itself. Left undetected, that systemic problem would have recurred, at enormous cost, both financial and personal.

 

“A failure is a clue. Whether you listen is a cultural choice.”

Zoë Reilly, SKAN US Sterility Assurance Sr. Technical Expert

Beyond blame: creating a culture of curiosity

I’ve sat through many aggressive meetings where tensions escalated quickly. Power dynamics are often uneven: QC microbiologists on one side, manufacturing teams on the other, with everyone under pressure and no one wanting to be in the wrong. In that environment, curiosity is usually the first thing to disappear.

A manufacturing lead once insisted the issue couldn’t be on their side and pushed a theory about product label adhesive. I disproved it directly—time and resources spent that could have gone toward the real question.

That kind of closed-mindedness comes at a high cost. Investigations can drag on for months, consuming time, energy, and resources. More importantly, it wastes the opportunity to learn what the failure is actually trying to reveal. In those cases, the real root cause isn’t a technical detail; it’s a culture that prioritizes self-preservation over understanding.

When leaders assume the answer before the investigation begins, that’s when learning stops.

Conclusion

How to build a culture that learns

  • Avoid tunnel vision

    Premature conclusions waste time, resources, and risk regulatory observation.

  • Make the space safe

    Cultivate the psychological safety needed for evidence to surface, even when it’s burdensome.

  • Root cause over bias

    It’s not about being right; it’s about finding root cause so the pattern doesn’t repeat.

  • Proactive, not reactive

    Don’t wait for a failure to expose weak points; scrutinize your processes continuously.

Want to learn more?

Well-trained teams catch the problem before it becomes a failure.

Back to top