Skip to content
Gerät welches

Built-in cleanability

How hygienic design shapes cleanability, from initial design to ongoing operation

Learn more

What looks cleanable isn’t always cleanable. This article maps cleanability across three critical stages: how it’s designed, how it’s proven, and how it’s preserved in operation.

EU GMP Annex 1 sets the expectation, but not the solution. It requires manufacturers to establish a contamination control strategy (CCS) that integrates equipment design, cleaning processes, and operational controls to maintain a state of control.

Yet what looks cleanable is not always cleanable. Mirror-polished surfaces can create a false sense of cleanliness, and surfaces with identical roughness values (Ra) can perform very differently during cleaning.

But while Annex 1 defines the state of control that must be achieved and maintained, it does not prescribe how cleanability should be engineered in practice.

„Visible clean is not sufficient. Cleanability must be demonstrated.“

Richard Denk, Senior Consultant Aseptic Processing & Containment, SKAN
Process

Cleanability is established, demonstrated, and maintained across three interconnected stages

  • 1

    Design

    Design establishes whether a system is cleanable in the first place.

  • 2

    Testing

    Testing demonstrates whether cleanability can be achieved under defined conditions.

  • 3

    Operations

    Operations determine whether cleanability is maintained over time.

1. Design: If design introduces contamination traps, cleaning and decontamination cannot reliably compensate

  • Design must eliminate inaccessible and contamination-prone areas.

    Gaps, recesses, and hidden areas can trap contamination and make surfaces inaccessible. Unnecessary fasteners, such as exposed screws in critical areas, should be avoided. All surfaces should be accessible from the HEPA filter down to the baseplate to ensure effective cleaning and decontamination.

  • Surface structure, not just roughness, determines cleanability.

    Surface roughness parameters such as Ra alone do not fully describe cleanability. Surfaces with identical Ra values can have very different microstructures, ranging from sharp, angular trenches to smooth, rounded topographies. Smoothness alone does not guarantee cleanability; what matters is the shape of those surface features.

    These microstructural variations significantly influence how residues adhere to surfaces and how effectively they can be removed during cleaning and decontamination.

  • Materials interact differently with residues and cleaning agents.

    Polymers and stainless steel interact differently with residues and cleaning agents, influencing how easily surfaces can be cleaned.

  • Cleanability must extend across the full process, not just the isolator system.

    Cleanability must extend beyond the isolator shell to include filling line interfaces and container transfer components, where contamination risks can arise.

2. Testing: How cleanability is demonstrated

  • Zersprungenes Glas am Boden mit neongrüner Flüssigkeit

    Simulate worst-case contamination

    Worst-case scenarios (e.g., vial breakage or splashing) are recreated in a controlled and reproducible way.

  • Swab

    Map and sample contamination

    Contamination spread is mapped to identify high-risk zones, and samples are collected from critical areas.

  • Tupfertest am Isolator in einem weissen Quadrat

    Verify cleaning effectiveness

    Residual contamination is measured to confirm that cleaning processes effectively remove it.

3. Operation: How cleanability changes over time

  • Surface wear and micro-damage

    Repeated cleaning, wiping, and handling introduce micro-scratches that alter surface structure.

  • Chemical interaction

    Cleaning agents and residues gradually modify surface properties.

  • Increased residue retention

    These changes can increase residue adhesion and make surfaces more difficult to clean.

Tests für Materialeignung

„Annex 1 emphasizes maintaining a state of control during routine operation, not just demonstrating it during validation.“

Richard Denk, Senior Consultant Aseptic Processing & Containment, SKAN

Why cleanability requires integrated expertise

Cleanability is not a single feature of equipment. It is the result of how design, validation, and operational practices interact across the lifecycle of an aseptic system.

Because these factors are interdependent, cleanability cannot be addressed through isolated decisions about surface finish or cleaning procedures alone. Achieving reliable contamination control requires the integration of hygienic design, validated cleaning performance, and disciplined operational practices.

Cleanability is built, proven, and preserved over time. Organizations that treat cleanability as a lifecycle consideration, rather than a single design parameter, are better positioned to maintain consistent aseptic conditions.

The critical question is whether cleanability has been engineered, demonstrated, and maintained across your system, or simply assumed.

Ready to evaluate your cleaning strategy?

Schedule a consultation with a SKAN expert.

Back to top